Overcommitted, but still strategic
Dear Overstretched Creatives,
This deep dive, reflecting on the results of our Overcommitted Report and my personal experience leading in-house creative teams, is my love letter to you.
Yours in greater calm and creativity,
Jen Rapp
It’s not talent, technology or passion. As a marketing leader overseeing creative teams for the last ten years, the biggest problem in-house creatives face today is bandwidth. Now, more than ever, they’re asked to do more and build more—faster and with fewer resources.
Every creative team I’ve overseen from DoorDash to Klaviyo, even here at Superside, is maxed out—battling burnout as a group and as individuals. No wonder the survey results from our Overcommitted Report came back saying 76% of creative professionals felt burnt out and 78% of their teams felt the same way.
Overcommitted? It’s just another word for in-house teams
In-house creative teams serve many stakeholders. They’re the guardians of the brand and gateway to creative assets for the sales team, marketing teams, event teams, product teams, people teams and more. Anything that requires graphics, video or design, comes to the creative team.
Source: The Overcommitted Report
Popularity comes with a price
Would you like fries with that? The rise of digital media was one of the main reasons in-house teams came to exist. Instead of print, TV and radio campaigns, the number of channels and creative formats has exploded—like Big Bang-level expansion—and it just keeps growing. And the fact that it’s all online, means the people making the requests accidentally underestimate the amount of work involved in creating, editing and versioning creative.
Have you seen our new menu items? The move toward motion, video, AR and immersive experiences takes more time to produce and requires highly specialized skill sets. The battle for attention is getting epically harder and ad lifespans are shrinking to nanoseconds, driving the need for non-stop testing and iteration at the speed of light.
Next? Please pull up to the window… Here’s the catch: No matter how big or small they are or how efficiently they work, in-house teams inevitably end up as a bottleneck—a choke point between their KPIs and the entire company’s creative assets. All the work comes into one team, it’s all urgent—and there’s no way to get it all done.
Can I get a little help here?
Most creative professionals, 70% of them, feel that their team’s best talents are wasted on work that’s well below their skill levels and much less strategic to growth.
The solution: When these teams hit maximum capacity—which is always—they outsource. But, it’s far from a perfect solution—with 85% of teams thinking they need to do a better job choosing what they outsource and who they work with.
The problem: Even the best freelancers and agencies aren’t built for today’s digitally driven, AI-infused landscape. Starting from scratch and determining the best partner for each project is no way to scale. It’s likely why 51% of creative professionals have lost faith in traditional agencies. Honestly, I’m surprised that number isn’t higher!
Source: The Overcommitted Report
There has to be a better way!
The times they are a changing. While traditional service providers struggle to adapt, failing to deliver on speed, quality and communication (or address a plethora of other performance challenges)—partners like Superside, have risen to the occasion.
Before I joined Superside as CMO, I was also a customer. In 2021, my creative team at Klaviyo was seriously swamped. After exploring our options, we hired Superside. Why? What stood out to me was that Superside understood what it meant to step in and act like an extension of our in-house team.
They didn’t try to replace our expertise, they amplified it by serving as an extension of our team. Suddenly, we had a creative team serving our creative team. Our team was able to move faster, get more done and be more creative, without hiring more people or spending our limited budget on a fancy agency.
Ultimately, with Superside by our side, our creative team was no longer the “blocker.” Our internal stakeholders were happier—here’s looking at you Thuan Tran on our Growth Team and Josh Mendelsohn in Product Marketing—and our creatives were happier too.
Enjoy the Overcommitted Report. There’s hope for every overcommitted creative on the planet. We got you!
What 200+ creative leaders had to say
There’s a reason we called it the Overcommitted Report.
But, is there light at the end of the carpal tunnel?
Superside Chief Marketing Officer, Jen Rapp has 20+ years of experience leading marketing teams and growing brands like Klaviyo, DoorDash, TOMS and Patagonia. She’s also an active rock climber, skydiver, mountaineer, paraglider, skier, Cessna pilot and proud mom. Connect with this full-time CMO and adventurer to talk about scaling design, mountains or both.
You may also like these
5 steps for comparing graphic design RFP responses
Enterprise companies use graphic design requests for proposals (RFPs) as part of a coherent, systematic process for evaluating prospective outsourced creative partners.Once a creative services RFP has been issued and the prospective partners have submitted their responses, it’s time to objectively compare these bids based on key criteria ranging from the quality of the creative to how each partner best supports your team.In this article, I’ll provide an overview of five main steps in comparing RFP responses.5 steps for comparing creative service RFP responsesExperience has taught me that evaluating RFP responses can be broken down into five steps—providing a repeatable framework that you can continually leverage and refine to find ideal creative partners.
The bold, the brave, the builders: Tips from Superside’s Insider summit
What does it take to build campaigns that resonate, scale and actually move the needle? At Superside’s Insider Summit, we got the answer straight from the source.Four bold creative leaders—Ty Haney (Outdoor Voices, Try Your Best), Andrei Vexler (Shopify, Kaseya), Udi Ledergor (Gong) and Maureen Carter (Nike, BET Networks)—pulled back the curtain on the strategies, systems and mindsets behind some of today’s most iconic marketing moves.From building community into a $100M growth engine to crafting scrappy stunts that look like they have Super Bowl budgets, the sessions were filled with actionable ideas and personal insights from the people who’ve actually done the work. These weren’t rehearsed case studies. They were the candid truths and hard-earned lessons behind breakthrough creative.Here are the biggest takeaways from the summit.1. Community is the new growth engine
How Superside’s CMO is redefining creative leadership in the age of AI
“Creative is the new targeting.” This mic-drop moment from Jen Rapp, Chief Marketing Officer at Superside, perfectly sums up the spirit of her conversation with Greg Kihlström on The Agile Brand Podcast.As brands continue to ride the AI wave, Rapp is steering Superside—and the broader marketing world—toward a creative-first future. From the opportunities AI opens up to navigating hesitance and differentiating through creative, here are the biggest takeaways from her podcast episode with Kihlström, no fluff, no filler.AI is not the enemy—it’s the opportunityRapp spent a decade leading marketing at Patagonia, before diving into the fast lanes of tech at DoorDash, Klaviyo and now Superside—an AI-powered creative service built to support bandwidth-stretched internal teams.She explained how Superside has made a bold bet: Go all in on AI. But beyond just adopting it, the company has trained all 500 of its global creatives on it. As Rapp put it, Superside reached a turning point.